The Houston Astros have built one of the most dynamic lineups in Major League Baseball over the past few seasons, and their future looks just as promising. However, with rumors swirling about third baseman Alex Bregman possibly leaving for one of the team’s rivals, fans are wondering how the Astros might adjust in the 2025 season. If Bregman were to depart, the team would need to fill his shoes with the right mix of power and consistency. Here’s a look at what the Astros’ lineup could look like without him and how they could remain one of the top teams in the league.
1. Jose Altuve (2B) Jose Altuve has been the heart and soul of the Astros for over a decade, and he’s still one of the best second basemen in the game. Despite being in the later stages of his career, Altuve continues to offer power, speed, and elite contact ability. As the leadoff hitter, Altuve would still set the tone for the Astros with his ability to get on base and turn any single into a potential extra-base hit.
2. Jeremy Pena (SS) Jeremy Pena has shown that he’s more than capable of stepping up as the Astros’ starting shortstop. Following his incredible postseason performance in 2022, Pena could prove to be the anchor at shortstop for years to come. His combination of power, speed, and defense makes him a great fit in the No. 2 hole, and he will look to build on his success in 2025.
3. Yordan Alvarez (DH) Yordan Alvarez has quickly established himself as one of the most dangerous power hitters in baseball. If Bregman were to leave, Alvarez would move to the No. 3 spot in the lineup, where he could fully showcase his immense power. His ability to hit for average and drive in runs with authority makes him a key player to watch for the Astros in 2025.
4. Kyle Tucker (RF) Kyle Tucker has developed into one of the league’s most complete hitters, combining power with excellent plate discipline. Tucker has also become a reliable defensive presence in the outfield, and in the No. 4 spot, he would provide the Astros with both protection for Alvarez and another big bat to drive in runs. With Bregman gone, Tucker could be the player the Astros lean on to deliver in the clutch.
5. Alex Bregman’s Replacement (3B) This is the most pressing question for the Astros if Bregman were to join a rival team. The Astros would likely look to either trade for a top-tier third baseman or promote one of their top prospects. Players like David Hensley or a potential trade acquisition could be options. Regardless of who fills the spot, it would be crucial to replace Bregman’s on-base skills, power, and leadership.
6. Michael Brantley (LF) Michael Brantley, when healthy, is one of the most consistent hitters in the game. The veteran outfielder could play a key role in the Astros’ lineup as a middle-of-the-order bat capable of getting on base and producing runs. Even in a new lineup dynamic, Brantley’s ability to hit for average would provide stability to the Astros’ offense.
7. Chas McCormick (CF) Chas McCormick has proven to be an emerging force in the Astros’ lineup. Known for his power, he can be an excellent complement to the top of the order. McCormick could fill the No. 7 spot in the lineup, offering protection for the hitters above him while providing a solid defensive presence in center field.
8. Martin Maldonado (C) While Martin Maldonado may not provide the offensive numbers of some other players, his defense and leadership behind the plate are invaluable. He would likely remain in the No. 8 spot, where he can help with pitch framing and managing the Astros’ pitching staff, while contributing when needed with his bat.
9. Backup Player/Utility (Various) The final spot in the lineup would likely be filled by a backup utility player. Players like Mauricio Dubon or a similar acquisition could rotate through infield or outfield positions, providing depth and a strategic advantage off the bench.
Conclusion If Alex Bregman were to leave the Astros and join a rival, it would be a significant blow to the team’s offense. However, with a strong core of players like Jose Altuve, Yordan Alvarez, and Kyle Tucker, the Astros would still be primed for another strong season in 2025. By filling Bregman’s shoes with the right additions—whether from within the organization or through trade—the Astros would remain competitive in the American League and continue to be a postseason contender.
