As the Houston Astros prepare for the start of the 2025 MLB season, the team faces a crucial decision that could have significant implications for their pitching rotation. With Opening Day set for March 27th, Astros owner Jim Crane, along with general manager Dana Brown and manager Dusty Baker, have been closely evaluating the pitching staff to determine who will serve as the team’s Number Two starter. This decision is particularly important given the Astros’ championship aspirations, as a solid one-two punch at the top of the rotation is critical for maintaining success over a 162-game season.
The competition for the Number Two spot has been fierce throughout spring training. The Astros, defending World Series champions, enter the season with a deep and talented roster. However, after ace Framber Valdez, who is slated to take the mound on Opening Day, the team faces a bit of uncertainty. Several candidates have emerged for the Number Two spot, each with their own strengths and weaknesses.
Lance McCullers Jr., a veteran presence in the Astros’ rotation, has been a mainstay for the team for several years. However, McCullers has dealt with injury issues in recent seasons, which has raised some concerns about his consistency and durability moving forward. While he has shown flashes of brilliance in the past, including a strong postseason performance, the lingering questions surrounding his health could make him a less reliable option as the Number Two starter.
Christian Javier, another strong candidate, had an outstanding year in 2024, contributing significantly to the Astros’ World Series run. With his dynamic stuff and ability to perform on the big stage, many consider Javier a natural fit for the Number Two spot. His fastball-curveball combination is elite, and his poise under pressure makes him a potential ace for any rotation. However, some have questioned whether he can consistently replicate his postseason success over the course of a full season.
The Astros also have some younger, emerging arms in the mix. Hunter Brown, a highly-touted prospect, impressed in his brief stint with the big league club in 2024 and has looked sharp in spring training. His powerful fastball and swing-and-miss stuff make him a tantalizing option for a spot in the starting rotation. However, the team may choose to keep him in a more developmental role for the time being, as they balance long-term potential with immediate needs.
The decision over the Number Two starter has put owner Jim Crane in a difficult position. As a businessman with a deep commitment to winning, Crane understands the importance of having a solid pitching staff, especially in a competitive division like the American League West. He has been closely monitoring the performances of each pitcher throughout spring training, trusting the expertise of the front office to help make the final decision.
Astros fans, who have grown accustomed to a high standard of excellence, are eagerly awaiting the announcement. With Valdez leading the rotation, the team feels confident in its ability to compete for another championship. However, the choice of who fills the Number Two role is essential to setting the tone for the season.
As the Astros prepare for their season opener against the rival Seattle Mariners, the front office will need to make a decision that balances current performance with long-term potential. Whether it’s McCullers’ veteran presence, Javier’s dynamic upside, or the raw talent of Hunter Brown, the choice will be a defining moment for the Astros’ pitching staff. Only time will tell who gets the nod, but one thing is certain: the Astros are ready to make a run at another title, and this decision could be a pivotal moment in that quest.
